I’ve liked Winters' other books but this one (where all the narrative characters are female or non-binary) just fell flat for me. Great plot, interesting concept but the women just didn’t feel like women, they felt like television’s idea of women. Like, if you have a character who is a domestic abuse survivor and then she gets killed in an unrelated (and ugly) way, you’ve decided she is a plot device and that’s a very specific authorial choice. It seemed strange and all the female characters seemed two dimensional. The non-binary character also turned out to be a plucky smartie but also they were treated in a not-particularly-interesting way. I loved the plot of this book, it was inventive and different, but the way it was handled I just couldn’t get behind.
{ search }
{ see all the books }
by author ... by title
by rating:
[ + ]
[ 0 ]
[ - ]
by category:
| all categories
| best in show
| biography
| collection
| fiction
| graphic novel
| librariana
| non-fiction
| poetry
| reference
| unfinished
| ya
{ 2024 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2023 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2022 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2021 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2020 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2019 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2018 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2017 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2016 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2015 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2014 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2013 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2012 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2011 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2010 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2009 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2008 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2007 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2006 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2005 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2004 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2003 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ 2002 }
jan | feb | mar | apr |
may | jun | jul | aug |
sep | oct | nov | dec |
{ change the font }
{ pre-oddbook }
Big Time